The Irrational Attacks on Planned Parenthood
At a collaboration meeting the other day, an organization we are trying to partner with told us in no uncertain terms that Planned Parenthood could not be a part of anything we did. Now, I understand that every person and organization is entitled to their own beliefs, and I respect that. I am not writing this because I think I’m on some moral high ground, or that the people who disagree with me are wrong because beliefs are just that – beliefs. They are not based on science or fact, logic or reason, but people still feel that their beliefs are fundamental truths in their own lives, and it is not my place to tell people how to feel.
However, if we could, for a moment examine why people are so vehemently opposed to the work the Planned Parenthood does. First of all, there’s the pro-life vs. pro-choice debate. Yes, Planned Parenthood provides women with abortions. Are abortions a moral, ethical way to deal with an unplanned pregnancy? I don’t know. If you believe that abortions are wrong, that is your belief, and you are entitled to that, but recognize that other people don’t feel that way, and should be just as entitled as you to feel that way. If you don’t believe in abortions, don’t get one. Why concern yourself with what other people do with their bodies? What business is it of anyone’s except that girl and her partner? Some would argue that it is also, at the very least, God’s business. God wouldn’t want people to get abortions, therefore it is wrong, and so we should fight to stop all abortions. Perhaps. I haven’t spoken with God about the issue, so I can’t say for sure one way or the other. But again, why concern yourself? Let’s assume, for the moment, that those who argue abortions are an abomination of Gods will are correct. If a person wants to get an abortion, then won’t they be judged by God? If you believe the word of God is to not get abortions, and you want to follow Gods will, then don’t get an abortion. Take care of your own life. Otherwise, let God do the judging and condemning.
Another attack I’ve been hearing recently about Planned Parenthood is that they help pimps of underage prostitutes and sex workers. The organization, Live Action, which “discovered” this, and claimed that Planned Parenthood had a “institutionalized willingness to aid and abet such sex traffickers” failed to mention that shortly after the videos were shot of Planned Parenthood employees supposedly helping these pimps, they (Planned Parenthood) had called the FBI to report suspected sex trafficking. Calling the FBI to report a suspected sex trafficker does not sound like “aiding and abetting” to me.
Lastly, there’s the nonsense of Planned Parenthood using taxpayer dollars to pay for abortions. This is simply not true. Yes Planned Parenthood gets federal funding, and yes they give abortions, but they are NOT allowed to use their federal funding for abortions. There has been an unfortunate trend going on where people post videos online where they talk about how Planned Parenthood provides abortions, and then immediately talk about how much taxpayer money Planned Parenthood receives, without mentioning the divide. This is a scare tactic, a misleading accusation meant to rile up the public against Planned Parenthood by leaving out key facts. This is like me telling everyone that last night Obama told me that he was going to appoint me ultimate ruler of the world, and that my first duty as world ruler would be to hang out with the aliens in area 51 learning about all their super-cool alien technology (they had the iPad 2 months ago). What I’m not telling you is how, right after that happened, my alarm went off, I got out of bed, and got ready for work. Same thing, only mine is more fun.
Contrary to what Abby Johnson says (that 98% of the services provided to pregnant women are for abortions, when in fact abortions only make up 3% of the services they give) Planned Parenthood does so much more than provide abortions. They work hard to avoid giving abortions. A large majority of their budget is used for education and research. They are constantly educating our youth about abstinence, safe sex, and how to use protection. In fact, 83% of the people who walk into a Planned Parenthood clinic will receive services and education on how to prevent an unintended pregnancy. Think about that for a second. Why would Planned Parenthood spend so much if its time and resources trying to prevent people from having unintended pregnancies, if abortions are, as some claim “their main source of corporate income.” When was the last time you walked into a clothing store and they lectured you on the virtues of living in a nudist colony? When was the last time you went to the deli at the supermarket and the butcher talked your ear off about how great it was to be a vegetarian? When you stop to think about it, all of the attacks and arguments against Planned Parenthood begin to break down.
Planned Parenthood does great work, necessary work. They will give you free or cheap condoms and birth control. They will give you free or cheap STD testing. I understand if you believe having an abortion is wrong, but all I ask is that you understand other people don’t believe that abortions are wrong. Planned Parenthood provides a vital health service to so many people who would otherwise not have access to this kind of health care, and it would be a shame if they were unable to keep providing this service because so many people got caught up in the hype, in the irrational attacks on Planned Parenthood.



